Book Review: The Redhead and the Fountain Pen by Ivan Scott
A charming epistolary romance filled with handwritten letters, unexpected connections, and feel-good storytelling that will delight fans of sweet, modern love stories.
There's something quietly magical about a story built on handwritten letters-and this one leans into that charm in all the best ways.
About the Book
The Redhead and the Fountain Pen By Ivan Scott
Series: The Redhead Series
Published by Independent Author on October 1, 2024
Genres: Romantic Comedy
Formats: Audiobook, eBook, Paperback
Pages: 281
What if you fell in love with someone, but never met them? All you have are their handwritten letters that captured your heart. Welcome to Mark Dawson’s world!
After having to leave his dream job and the softball team he loves, Mark moves from Atlanta to the mountains of north Georgia to escape his past. When he visits a used bookstore and finds a letter in a copy of his favorite book, The Great Gatsby, he finds a kindred spirit. The only thing he knows about the woman is her name is Catherine, she lives in Manhattan, and has a broken heart.
Since neither are on social media, the only thing they know about each other comes from their words written in letters by a fountain pen.
Eventually, Mark’s feelings get the better of him, and he searches for Catherine. But what will happen when they finally come face to face? Will their love be signed, sealed and delivered? Or will it be three strikes for love?
Reader resources:
Curious to learn more or see what other readers think? Explore the book here:
View The Redhead and the Fountain Pen on Goodreads
View The Redhead and the Fountain Pen on StoryGraph
Review at a Glance
| Genre: | Romantic Comedy, Contemporary Romance |
| Setting: | Modern-day, small-town/bookshop vibes |
| Series: | The Redhead Series |
| Length: | Quick, light read |
| Content Rating: | Clean romance |
| My Rating: | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
A cozy, feel-good romance with handwritten charm and classic romcom energy.
- Clean romance (no explicit content)
- Light emotional themes around relationships and breakups
With that in mind, here are my thoughts on The Redhead and the Fountain Pen.
My Thoughts
The Redhead and the Fountain Pen by Ivan Scott is a charming romantic comedy built around one simple but irresistible premise: a found letter, a leap of curiosity, and the beginning of something unexpected.
Mark, a high school softball coach, discovers a breakup letter tucked inside a used bookshop find. Instead of ignoring it, he reaches out to its mysterious author, Catherine-and what follows is a heartfelt exchange of handwritten letters that slowly deepens into something more.
The epistolary format gives this story a unique intimacy. Watching their connection unfold through letters adds a layer of anticipation and emotional authenticity that feels both nostalgic and refreshingly personal.
Scott's storytelling shines in the small details-the humor, the warmth, and the easy chemistry between characters. The slow-burn romance develops naturally, making this an especially satisfying read for fans of feel-good love stories.
I've become such a fan of the Redhead series, and this installment continues that trend. Each book somehow manages to feel like the best one yet, and this one is no exception.
Between the bookshop setting, the nod to The Great Gatsby, and the handwritten letters, this story carries strong You've Got Mail energy-but with a more personal, heartfelt twist.
Even without ever meeting Ivan Scott or his real-life inspiration, it's clear there's something special behind these stories. They consistently deliver warmth, charm, and that unmistakable "smile when you finish" feeling.
Start the Series
If you're new to the Redhead series, I recommend starting with
Redhead in a Blue Convertible,
where the charm, humor, and heart of this series first come to life.
In Conclusion
If you love cozy romances, bookshop settings, and stories that lean into connection over chaos, this book is an easy recommendation.
This is the kind of book you pick up when you want something uplifting, engaging, and just a little bit magical in its simplicity.
Before we wrap up, here's a little more about the author behind the story.
About Ivan Scott
About Ivan Scott
Ivan Scott has lived in Atlanta for over 30 years. He is married to a Genuine Ginger, so having a redhead protagonist is a must.
He lives with his beautifully saucy wife, two troublemaking kids, and a Rat Terrier named Beesley in the Atlanta suburb of Sandy Springs.
He is diehard Detroit Lions fan (Yes, one of the few remaining), and like Billy from the story, he has a huge collection of the three B's: Bourbon, Bowties, and of course, Books!
Explore more from the author:
Website | Amazon | Goodreads
Thanks for reading. If this sounds like your kind of story, you can explore purchase options below.
Support Local Bookshops
Prefer to support independent bookstores? You can shop The Redhead and the Fountain Pen through Bookshop.org below.
If the widget does not load right away, you can refresh the page or use the direct Bookshop link above.
Happy reading - and thank you for supporting indie authors and stories worth discovering.
Get Friday Finds + Bookish Extras
Join me for Friday Finds, cozy reads, and bookish discoveries delivered straight to your inbox.
I'm a natural redhead with natural curly hair no grey yet so would love to read these redhead books in print format
I need to check this out! Love epistolary!