BBNYA 2025 Finalist Review: Soul Fraud by Andrew Givler | A Darkly Funny Supernatural Review
A clever blend of dark humor and supernatural intrigue, where soul collection feels less like damnation-and more like a very strange day at the office.
Some stories take familiar systems and turn them just enough to make you see them differently-and Soul Fraud by Andrew Givler does exactly that. What starts as a structured, almost corporate-feeling world quickly reveals something far more imaginative, where debts aren't just financial and the stakes reach well beyond the living.
Set within the strangely bureaucratic world of Hell Corporate, this story blends supernatural elements with a surprisingly light touch. Demons, deals, and even the devil's inner circle are presented through a lens that balances tension with humor, creating a tone that feels more clever than heavy. With that in mind, here are my thoughts on Soul Fraud.
Welcome to my stop on the 2025 BBNYA Finalist Tour
The Book Bloggers' Novel of the Year Award (BBNYA) celebrates standout indie fiction, and I always love being part of that discovery process.
Today's post is a review of Soul Fraud by Andrew Givler, one of this year's finalists.
This review is part of my ongoing mission here at GinaRaeMitchell.com to champion indie authors and stories worth discovering.
About BBNYA
The Book Bloggers' Novel of the Year Award (BBNYA) is a yearly competition that helps readers discover exceptional indie books.
Learn more about BBNYA:
BBNYA Website
@BBNYA_Official on X
@The_WriteReads on X
About Soul Fraud by Andrew Givler
Soul Fraud By Andrew Givler
Series: Debt Collection, #1
Published by Sad Seagull Publishing on 06/28/2022
Genres: Contemporary Fantasy
Formats: Audiobook, eBook, Hardcover, Paperback
Pages: 364
Matthew Carver has a terrible life. Seriously - it's awful. It is so bad that Dan the Demon is shocked when Matt turns down his infernal offer: ten years of a blissful life in exchange for his soul.
But Dan is a salesman behind on his quota and his demonic managers are running out of patience. He forges Matt's signature on the dotted line, stealing his soul and thrusting him into a supernatural world he never knew existed.
Now Matt must figure out how to get his soul back and stop a war before it is too late...
A Supernatural Workplace with a Darkly Funny Twist
Reader Resources
Curious to learn more or see what other readers think? Explore the book here:
Review at a Glance
| Genre: | Supernatural Thriller / Dark Humor |
| Setting: | Hell Corporate (a bureaucratic underworld) |
| Series: | Debt Collection #1 |
| Length: | Medium-length novel |
| Content Rating: | Adult (supernatural themes, dark humor, some language) |
| My Rating: | ★★★★☆ |
| Quick Take: | A smart, darkly funny take on soul collection wrapped in a supernatural corporate world. |
Before we get into my full thoughts, here's a quick note for readers:
Content Considerations
- Supernatural themes involving demons, Hell, and soul collection
- Dark humor throughout (balances heavier concepts)
- Moral ambiguity and deal-making
- Some language consistent with adult fiction
Beneath the humor and unusual setting, the story still finds room to explore the choices that define us.
My Thoughts
This is one of those stories that leans into its premise and makes the most of it. The idea of soul collection framed through a corporate structure is both creative and surprisingly effective, giving the story a unique rhythm that feels familiar and completely original at the same time.
The tone is where this book really shines. While the subject matter could easily become heavy, there's a consistent thread of humor running underneath it all. It softens the darker edges without removing them entirely, creating a balance that keeps the story engaging rather than overwhelming.
Characters add to that balance in meaningful ways. Figures like Lilith bring a sense of real presence and danger, but even those moments are offset by the story's slightly offbeat perspective. It creates a world that feels layered-part intimidating, part oddly relatable.
The setting of Hell Corporate is particularly well done. Treating something traditionally portrayed as chaotic or terrifying as structured and procedural adds a fresh twist, and it allows the story to explore its themes from a different angle. It's less about fear and more about how systems-no matter where they exist-shape behavior and choices.
What stood out most is how naturally the humor and darker elements coexist. Neither one overwhelms the other, and that balance gives the story its distinct voice.
In the end, Soul Fraud offers a creative and unexpectedly entertaining take on the idea of soul collection, blending humor, supernatural elements, and thoughtful character work into a story that feels both unique and accessible.
Where to Buy
If this intriguing finalist feels like your kind of read, you can explore purchase options below.
Support Local Bookshops
If you prefer to shop local, you can purchase Soul Fraud through independent bookstores using Bookshop.org.
Kindle | Paperback | Hardcover | Audiobook
Meet Andrew Givler
About Andrew Givler
Andrew Givler is the author of The Debt Collection & Ironbound series. He is also a gaming YouTuber known as Sigils with over 1.4 million subscribers.
He loves making people laugh, video games, and food. (Not always in that order.) He lives in LA.
Explore more from the author:
Website | Amazon | Goodreads
More 2025 BBNYA Finalists
If you're enjoying these finalists, here are a few more worth exploring:
- Speak the Ocean by Rebecca Enzor
- Miss Bennet's Dragon by M. Verant
- Bella's Countryside Christmas by Claire Huston
Thanks for spending part of your day with me. If you enjoy stories that mix the supernatural with a touch of humor and a fresh perspective, Soul Fraud is a fun and memorable one to add to your list.
If you read Soul Fraud, let me know what your think - I'd love to compare notes.
Happy reading - and thank you for supporting indie authors and stories worth discovering.
Get Friday Finds + Bookish Extras
Join me for Friday Finds, cozy reads, and bookish discoveries delivered straight to your inbox.
[…] Soul Fraud […]