The Weight of Amber by Eleanor Vane | Historical Fantasy Romance Review
A richly atmospheric blend of historical intrigue, witch trial danger, and slow-burn romance.
I enjoy a well-told story that sends me down the research rabbit hole. I was familiar with the Salem witch trials, but the Scottish witch trials were largely new to me. That alone made The Weight of Amber an intriguing read before I even met its characters.
In this review of The Weight of Amber by Eleanor Vane, I share what worked for me, where the story stands out, and who I think will connect with it most.
About The Weight of Amber
The Weight of Amber By Eleanor Vane
Series: The Thornfield Inheritance #1
on May 2026
Genres: Historical Fantasy
Formats: eBook, Paperback
Pages: 322
She reads the history in everything she touches. He is the most dangerous thing she has ever held.
Scotland, 1593. Ailis Thornfield has a gift she cannot afford to name: when she touches an object, she feels its history. A wedding ring grows heavy with decades of love. A knife burns with the memory of blood. She has survived as an herbalist in the Scottish borderlands by hiding what she can do behind knowledge that looks like intuition and cures that look like luck.
Her mother was not so careful. Her mother burned.
When a series of witch accusations sweep the border villages the English Crown sends a magistrate to investigate. James Blackwood is young, educated, and inconveniently principled. He has been sent to find evidence of ungodly practices. He is finding something else entirely: a woman whose impossible knowledge is the only thing standing between the border villages and a conspiracy designed to destroy them.She cannot trust the man who holds her life in his legal authority. He cannot trust a woman whose abilities defy everything he was taught at Cambridge. But the conspiracy is real, the witch trials are escalating, and the only way to stop what is coming is to work together — and risk everything on the possibility that the man sent to judge her might be the first person in her life who sees what she is and does not flinch.
Enemies to lovers. Slow burn. 1590s Scotland. No one is safe.
Reader Resources
Explore ratings, reviews, and more:
Review at a Glance
| Genre | Historical Fantasy Romance |
| Series | The Thornfield Inheritance #1 |
| Setting | Scottish Borderlands, 1593 |
| Length | Character-Driven Series Opener ~ 322 pages |
| Content Rating | Ages 16+ (witch trials, religious persecution, referenced executions, period violence) |
| My Rating | ★★★★☆ (4 stars) |
| Quick Take | A richly atmospheric blend of historical intrigue, witch trial danger, and slow-burn romance that lays a strong foundation for the Thornfield Inheritance series. |
Content Considerations:
- Witch trials
- Referenced executions
- Period-accurate violence
- Religious persecution
With that in mind, this is where things really take shape.
My Thoughts on The Weight of Amber
The Weight of Amber combines historical fiction, light fantasy elements, and slow-burn romance against the backdrop of the Scottish Witch Trials. The premise immediately caught my attention. A heroine who can read the history of objects through touch offers an intriguing lens through which to explore a period already filled with fear, suspicion, and injustice.
Ailis is an easy character to root for. Her gift is both fascinating and dangerous, and the constant threat of discovery creates tension throughout the story. I also enjoyed the dynamic between Ailis and James. Their relationship develops gradually, allowing trust to build naturally rather than rushing the romance. Readers looking for a gentle enemies-to-lovers arc will likely appreciate the measured pace.
The historical setting is one of the book's greatest strengths. Eleanor Vane clearly understands the era she is writing about, and her descriptive style brings sixteenth-century Scotland vividly to life. The atmosphere often feels as important as the plot itself, with the looming threat of witch accusations hanging over nearly every chapter.
While the story held my interest throughout, there were a few sections in the middle where the pacing slowed and some ideas felt slightly repetitive. As the first installment in a larger series, the novel also spends considerable time establishing the world, characters, and long-term mysteries. Readers who enjoy expansive series foundations will appreciate this approach, though those seeking a fully resolved story may find themselves eager for the next book before all their questions are answered.
Overall, I found The Weight of Amber to be a solid and engaging beginning to The Thornfield Inheritance. The combination of historical intrigue, atmospheric storytelling, and a compelling magical gift left me interested in seeing where the series goes next.
In Conclusion
If you enjoy historical fantasy that places character development and atmosphere ahead of fast-paced action, The Weight of Amber is worth a look. The Scottish Witch Trials provide a compelling backdrop for a story filled with secrets, suspicion, and slow-growing trust.
With an appealing heroine, a well-researched historical setting, and several unanswered mysteries still waiting to unfold, this first installment successfully lays the groundwork for the books to come. I'm curious to see what revelations await both Ailis and readers in the next chapter of the Thornfield family story.
If you enjoy atmospheric historical fiction with touches of the supernatural, you might also enjoy my review of The Witch of Breton Woods by Jennifer Ivy Walker.
Before we wrap up, here's a little more about the author behind the story.
About Eleanor Vane
About Eleanor Vane
Eleanor Vane holds an MA in Early Modern European History and spent years working in museum archives before turning to fiction. She lives in Edinburgh and travels extensively to research the settings of her novels.
Her debut series, The Thornfield Inheritance, spans five centuries and three continents, following generations of Thornfield women bound by a centuries-old pact and the gift of reading emotional residue on objects. Blending sweeping historical fiction with slow-burn romance, her work explores the connections between memory, history, and the objects we leave behind.
Explore more from the author:
Website | Amazon | Goodreads
Thanks for reading. If this sounds like your kind of story, you can explore purchase options below.
Where to Buy
Prefer shopping elsewhere? You can also browse my favorite book retailers:
Kobo |
Bookshop.org
This post may contain affiliate links. This means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you if you make a purchase through these links. Thank you for supporting my blog and helping me continue to champion indie authors and stories worth discovering.
Happy reading - and thank you for supporting indie authors and stories worth discovering.
Get Friday Finds + Bookish Extras
Join me for Friday Finds, cozy reads, and bookish discoveries delivered straight to your inbox.
Leave a comment